Generative AI Policy

AMJEL recognises that authors and reviewers may use generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) and AI-assisted tools in their scholarly work. This policy permits such tools only as supporting aids for clearly defined technical tasks, requires every use to be disclosed by naming the specific tool, and keeps all intellectual and scholarly judgement with humans. The policy is consistent with the COPE position statement on authorship and AI tools.

1. General Principles

  • AI tools are aids, not contributors. The research ideas, arguments, analysis, interpretation, conclusions, review judgements, and editorial decisions must be produced by humans.
  • Every use of AI must be declared, including the name of the tool. Undisclosed use of AI is not acceptable.
  • AI tools cannot be listed as authors or co-authors, because they cannot take responsibility for the work, approve the final manuscript, or declare conflicts of interest.

2. Permitted Use by Authors

Authors may use AI tools only for the following supporting tasks:

  1. checking numbers, calculations, statistical output, and the consistency of figures reported in the text, tables, and figures;
  2. polishing language, grammar, and readability, or translating text originally written by the authors;
  3. checking the formatting and completeness of the manuscript and reference list against the AMJEL template.

Authors must not use AI tools to generate research ideas, literature reviews, arguments, findings, interpretations, or conclusions; to create, alter, or manipulate data or images; or to generate references. Every cited reference must be verified by the authors against its original source. Fabricated or non-existent references are treated as research misconduct.

3. Permitted Use by Reviewers

Reviewers may use AI tools only for the following supporting tasks:

  1. checking numbers, calculations, and the statistical consistency of results reported in the manuscript;
  2. polishing the language of the review report that the reviewer has written.

The assessment of the manuscript and the recommendation to the editor must be the reviewer's own judgement. To protect confidentiality, reviewers must not enter author names or identifying details into AI tools, should enter only the specific passages or tables needed for the permitted task rather than the full manuscript, and must use only tools whose settings do not retain the content or use it for model training.

4. Use by Editors

Editors may use AI tools only for language checking, similarity screening, and reference checking, under the same confidentiality safeguards that apply to reviewers. All editorial decisions are made by human editors.

5. Mandatory Disclosure: Naming the AI Tool

A disclosure must not be left blank. Authors must include a section titled Declaration of Generative AI Use before the References, stating:

  1. the name of the AI tool and its provider (for example, ChatGPT by OpenAI, Claude by Anthropic, Gemini by Google, Grammarly, or QuillBot);
  2. the version or model, where known;
  3. the purpose of use (number checking, language polishing, or format checking);
  4. the sections of the manuscript in which the tool was used;
  5. a statement that the authors reviewed the output and take full responsibility for the content.

Example statement: "During the preparation of this manuscript, the authors used [tool name, version, provider] to [check the calculations in Tables 2–4 / polish the English language of the Introduction and Discussion]. After using this tool, the authors reviewed and edited the content as needed and take full responsibility for the content of the publication."

If no AI tool was used, authors must state: "No generative AI or AI-assisted tools were used in the preparation of this manuscript."

Reviewers must declare in their comments to the editor the name of any AI tool used and its purpose, or state that no AI tool was used.

6. Responsibility

Authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality, and integrity of their manuscript, and reviewers remain fully responsible for the content of their reports, regardless of whether AI tools were used.

7. Non-Compliance

Suspected undisclosed or inappropriate use of AI will be handled in accordance with the AMJEL Publication Ethics policy and may result in a request for clarification, rejection of the manuscript, or correction or retraction of a published article. Review reports that breach this policy may be disregarded, and the reviewer may be removed from the reviewer pool.

This policy will be reviewed as international standards on the use of AI in scholarly publishing evolve. Last updated: November 2026.